Finkdachef Posted October 1, 2018 Posted October 1, 2018 (edited) Anyone made purchases before or have any experience with these speakers? https://www.aliexpress.com/store/product/Queenway-6-5-inch-Scan-speak-D2904-710003-Neodymium-tweeter-18WU8741-floor-landing-speaker-DIY/1070003_32889550085.html?spm=2114.12010612.8148356.64.b89171d8iCHUvp http://www.hifi-elite.com/onlyforbea.htm Elite Asethet They are using the same scanspeak drivers in other western brands but cost a fraction of the price. Edited October 1, 2018 by Finkdachef
Soundasme Posted October 1, 2018 Posted October 1, 2018 Isn't the B&W 800 series speakers made (at least in part) in China?
MattyW Posted October 1, 2018 Posted October 1, 2018 (edited) I have checked out those speakers before though ended up getting two other pairs of Chinese speakers. Aurum Cantus F620 - 89db 4ohm with ribbon tweeters - Used in my main living room system. Spectacular though seem to respond well to a bit of power so solid state amplification for these. When fed sufficient power these have a flat response with deep and tight bass and sparkling, airy highs. Oatlon W2-1000F (aka Kingprints W2-1000F) - 97db 4ohm speakers with dual 10" drivers for bass & mids, horn tweeter - works extremely well with my 45WPC Oldchen KT88-K3 amp. Far better than the Aurum Cantus F620 speakers with that amp. Flat frequency response, less very natural highs, great mids and incredible bass. Seems to get along extremely well with Western Electric 11GA tinned copper speaker wire, which makes it more dynamic and punchy than it is with say, Van Damme LC-OFC copper cable. Stunning speakers to look at too Edited October 1, 2018 by MattyW 1
Al.M Posted October 1, 2018 Posted October 1, 2018 (edited) On 01/10/2018 at 5:30 AM, Finkdachef said: Anyone made purchases before or have any experience with these speakers? https://www.aliexpress.com/store/product/Queenway-6-5-inch-Scan-speak-D2904-710003-Neodymium-tweeter-18WU8741-floor-landing-speaker-DIY/1070003_32889550085.html?spm=2114.12010612.8148356.64.b89171d8iCHUvp http://www.hifi-elite.com/onlyforbea.htm Elite Asethet They are using the same scanspeak drivers in other western brands but cost a fraction of the price. Expand If they have used original Scanspeak drivers and sorted crossover design etc it could be a good deal. The tweeters are about $330 and woofers $370 each so $1400 worth to a DIYer but to a speaker manufacturer much less so with cheap Chinese labour costs quite possible. $600 delivery from China so all up $3k for floorstanders and what can you get for that elsewhere? Pictures of Scanspeak drivers below with the Illuminator woofer of particular note Edited October 1, 2018 by Al.M 1
MattyW Posted October 1, 2018 Posted October 1, 2018 If you do take the plunge I'd be very interested in reading your review. They appear beautifully made.
pete_mac Posted October 1, 2018 Posted October 1, 2018 I run a pair of the Elite Aesthet 1 Mk 2 speakers in my system. They are the best standmounts that I’ve owned in a list which includes Dynaudio, Lenehan, Focus Audio, Usher and others. The build quality is fantastic and they sound superb! I was fortunate to buy them locally, so I didn’t need to import them myself. 1 1
Guest Muon N' Posted October 1, 2018 Posted October 1, 2018 @pete_mac You have had those Elite's in your system for some years now, haven't you? Definitely a positive sign, and they must like the Sansui's
pete_mac Posted October 1, 2018 Posted October 1, 2018 On 01/10/2018 at 7:01 PM, Muon N' said: @pete_mac You have had those Elite's in your system for some years now, haven't you? Definitely a positive sign, and they must like the Sansui's Expand Indeed, nearly four years, and that’s a record for me. Very much content with what these beasties have to offer. 3
BruceS Posted October 1, 2018 Posted October 1, 2018 When it comes to conventional speakers, as opposed to say, electrostats, you need to listen to the speaker. Not some reviewer or an on line 'expert'. I was absolutely amazed at how good the Legend speakers were at last year's HiFi show. Fantastic value also!! Why buy a pig in a poke when you can listen!! Just something to think about. Hope that helps. Bruce 2
Al.M Posted October 2, 2018 Posted October 2, 2018 Still very tempting at least on paper if one places value on driver component value compared to what are being used in other commercial speaker choice at as low as 1/4 the driver value and value sold at 2-5 times the rrp. This scenario has been repeated ten years ago in Proac Response 2.5 floorstander copies sold at $2k vs the original $10k and the clone sounded very good. Picture of Elites below
pete_mac Posted October 2, 2018 Posted October 2, 2018 On 01/10/2018 at 10:45 PM, BruceS said: When it comes to conventional speakers, as opposed to say, electrostats, you need to listen to the speaker. Not some reviewer or an on line 'expert'. I was absolutely amazed at how good the Legend speakers were at last year's HiFi show. Fantastic value also!! Why buy a pig in a poke when you can listen!! Just something to think about. Hope that helps. Bruce Expand Hope you’re not having a crack at the so-called ‘on-line experts’ who are only trying to help via this thread? hehe My interest is piqued re: why electrostats are exempt from this rule? On 02/10/2018 at 12:46 AM, Al.M said: Still very tempting at least on paper if one places value on driver component value compared to what are being used in other commercial speaker choice at as low as 1/4 the driver value and value sold at 2-5 times the rrp. This scenario has been repeated ten years ago in Proac Response 2.5 floorstander copies sold at $2k vs the original $10k and the clone sounded very good. Picture of Elites below Expand That’s a pic from my system! 1
cafe67 Posted October 2, 2018 Posted October 2, 2018 On 01/10/2018 at 5:30 AM, Finkdachef said: Anyone made purchases before or have any experience with these speakers? https://www.aliexpress.com/store/product/Queenway-6-5-inch-Scan-speak-D2904-710003-Neodymium-tweeter-18WU8741-floor-landing-speaker-DIY/1070003_32889550085.html?spm=2114.12010612.8148356.64.b89171d8iCHUvp http://www.hifi-elite.com/onlyforbea.htm Elite Asethet They are using the same scanspeak drivers in other western brands but cost a fraction of the price. Expand Would they be genuine scanspeak etc drivers or chinese copies ?? 1
pete_mac Posted October 2, 2018 Posted October 2, 2018 (edited) On 02/10/2018 at 2:01 AM, cafe67 said: Would they be genuine scanspeak etc drivers or chinese copies ?? Expand Speaking from experience re: the Elite Aesthet 1s that I own, the tweeters are genuine, but a recent inspection and subsequent research revealed that the woofers are actually the Usher 8945. Apart from the false advertising element, this is not necessarily a bad thing at all - these woofers are basically Scanspeak clones which measure superbly according to info on the ‘net. Edit: sorry, I missed the question re: Scanspeak drivers in the OP, otherwise I would have answered this earlier. Edited October 2, 2018 by pete_mac
Finkdachef Posted October 2, 2018 Author Posted October 2, 2018 On 01/10/2018 at 12:05 PM, Al.M said: If they have used original Scanspeak drivers and sorted crossover design etc it could be a good deal. The tweeters are about $330 and woofers $370 each so $1400 worth to a DIYer but to a speaker manufacturer much less so with cheap Chinese labour costs quite possible. $600 delivery from China so all up $3k for floorstanders and what can you get for that elsewhere? Pictures of Scanspeak drivers below with the Illuminator woofer of particular note Expand This model looks like a clone of one of Fritzspeaker's floor stander using the same scan speak drivers. Fritz are retailing those for at least 4-5k USD. For sure they are using genuine scanspeak parts but nothing is known about the built quality and type of internal transistor parts are being used. http://www.fritzspeakers.com/custom_finishes.asp The elite asethets are a much safer bet. Besides Pete_mac, there are other superb reviews (translated from Chinese) and those are quite well known speakers in the Chinese market. Currently, I own a pair of Dynaudios excite x12 and am looking for a reasonable upgrade without breaking the bank. 1
cafe67 Posted October 2, 2018 Posted October 2, 2018 On 02/10/2018 at 2:19 AM, pete_mac said: Speaking from experience re: the Elite Aesthet 1s that I own, the tweeters are genuine, but a recent inspection and subsequent research revealed that the woofers are actually the Usher 8945. Apart from the false advertising element, this is not necessarily a bad thing at all - these woofers are basically Scanspeak clones which measure superbly according to info on the ‘net. Edit: sorry, I missed the question re: Scanspeak drivers in the OP, otherwise I would have answered this earlier. Expand Ahh i was looking at the photo of the light wood ztandmount and thought the woofer looked like what i had in my old usher be718 and md-1 . Thanks for the clarification 1
pete_mac Posted October 2, 2018 Posted October 2, 2018 (edited) On 02/10/2018 at 2:57 AM, cafe67 said: Ahh i was looking at the photo of the light wood ztandmount and thought the woofer looked like what i had in my old usher be718 and md-1 . Thanks for the clarification Expand Good spotting!! The Usher drivers are virtually identical to the Scanspeak 18W/8545 drivers i.e. https://www.madisoundspeakerstore.com/scanspeak-woofers-6-7/scanspeak-classic-18w/8545-01-7-mid-woofer-paper-cone/ It was only when I started looking closer at the cast woofer basket and speaker terminals that I noticed the slight variations. Edited October 2, 2018 by pete_mac
BruceS Posted October 2, 2018 Posted October 2, 2018 Why are electrostats exempt from the usual speaker listen process? Good question!! Seems to me that conventional speakers have an amazing variation in 'sound'. Hey, some cone speaker can sound a little like an electrostatic but just a little!! Bye and large electrostats have a very distinctive sound that you either like or you don't. Rephrasing, each electrostatic speaker, from one brand to the next has a very small variation in sound whereas cone speakers have a very large variation in sound between brands and models. Can be specific if you really want. I am an electrostatic owner but I make it my business to listen to all the different speakers when I go to the HIFi show. Hey, I will be doing exactly that next week!! Bruce
pete_mac Posted October 2, 2018 Posted October 2, 2018 Elite Aesthet 1: Ushers for sale: If you look at the pics of the Scanspeak in the link above, you will note the different terminals and basket. 1
BruceS Posted October 2, 2018 Posted October 2, 2018 Oh, by the way was not having a poke at anyone. But, how can a stranger on line know what you like? How can anyone anywhere know what sounds good to you? Same goes for the best speaker reviewer in the world, rowdies he know what sounds good to you? Depends on the individual person and also on the music that you like! Can't help thinking of a recent HiFi show where I asked a for my 'test' CD (multi part acapella music) to be played through a very high profile expensive speaker. Sounded terrible and the guy was visibly embarrassed when he returned my CD. No pokes just some observations. Bruce 1
pete_mac Posted October 2, 2018 Posted October 2, 2018 On 02/10/2018 at 3:18 AM, BruceS said: Oh, by the way was not having a poke at anyone. But, how can a stranger on line know what you like? How can anyone anywhere know what sounds good to you? Same goes for the best speaker reviewer in the world, rowdies he know what sounds good to you? Depends on the individual person and also on the music that you like! Can't help thinking of a recent HiFi show where I asked a for my 'test' CD (multi part acapella music) to be played through a very high profile expensive speaker. Sounded terrible and the guy was visibly embarrassed when he returned my CD. No pokes just some observations. Bruce Expand I understand where you’re coming from, and I generally agree - speakers are best heard before buying if possible. We all have different ears and preferences. However... this isn’t always achievable, and unless you hear them in your actual system and room, any pre-purchase listen is only a fair guesstimation of how they will actually sound in your room, and with your gear. The difference between a showroom and your room is often enormous! I’d be inclined to throw ‘stats into the same basket as any other speaker though - you should endeavor to hear them before committing your coin. They aren’t for everyone. 1
Stump Posted October 2, 2018 Posted October 2, 2018 On 02/10/2018 at 2:01 AM, cafe67 said: Would they be genuine scanspeak etc drivers or chinese copies ?? Expand I was thinking the same .Anything imported to China comes with high import duty.To then export for that price should be treated with caution .Even if fakes, you may not even hear any difference as China makes some great speakers.... Stump[
Finkdachef Posted October 2, 2018 Author Posted October 2, 2018 There is no doubt that the mentioned speakers are using genuine parts but the question is whether they can replicate the "magic" as found in scan speak based speakers such as Pro Arc. 1
Gryffles Posted October 2, 2018 Posted October 2, 2018 Ah, I have strong doubt @Finkdachef that parts are genuine
Finkdachef Posted October 2, 2018 Author Posted October 2, 2018 On 02/10/2018 at 5:57 AM, Gryffles said: Ah, I have strong doubt @Finkdachef that parts are genuine Expand This model seems too good to be true. I am still waiting for their reply on the crossover parts used and more photos of the finished product. https://www.aliexpress.com/store/product/Queenway-6-5-inch-Scan-speak-D2904-710003-Neodymium-tweeter-18WU8741-floor-landing-speaker-DIY/1070003_32889550085.html?spm=2114.12010612.8148356.64.b89171d8iCHUvp There is no doubt about the quality of the elite asethets as it has been around for awhile and there are quite a number of satisfied users.
Recommended Posts